Most users ever online was 263 on 2020-Apr-18 20:02
Users in total:
Newest user:
26 users online:
22,041
Ashlander
sydneygas 51 minutes ago

one more again

sydneygas 1 h 15 min ago

one more needed

sydneygas 1 h 17 min ago

3p live is up

D_jaja 1 h 17 min ago

Silver Den game started

D_jaja 1 h 48 min ago

2/3

D_jaja 1 h 55 min ago

3p live up

IronStandsEternal 15 hours ago

3/6p... you are welcome to join

IronStandsEternal 15 hours ago

3/6p

IronStandsEternal 16 hours ago

2/6p

IronStandsEternal 16 hours ago

6p live game is up in case someone wants to play

D_jaja 16 hours ago

2/3

D_jaja 16 hours ago

3p live up

D_jaja 18 hours ago

2/3

D_jaja 18 hours ago

Ok no interest in 6P live, then maybe 3P?

D_jaja 19 hours ago

How much players?

JaqenHghar0 19 hours ago

pbem for beginners?

D_jaja 20 hours ago

Lets try it... 6P live up

smssf 23 hours ago

hostless 3p live

Silver Den 23 hours ago

Legend, thank you very much

Ihor 23 hours ago

Done

Hail to JM Grip!



Community Forum
Search |  


Author
Message
NaKraWedzi
Master Blacksmith

Posts: 25
Games: 53
Rank Points: 243
Member since: 2017-Nov-01

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Sep-30 13:57
Hello,
recently in my game we lost with wildlings with card The Horde Descends.
Baratheon was considered lowest bider and he had to:
"Baratheon has to destroy 2 units at one of his Castles or Strongholds instead of 1 unit anywhere."
and he destroyed ships in Blackwater Bay.
Should it be allowed? He can muster ships there, so it counts as a castle area? I will add that he had land units available.
Harakon
Grandmaester of Reports

Posts: 3,634
Games: 903
Rank Points: 3,430
Member since: 2014-Aug-24

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Sep-30 14:05
Hi NaKraWedzi

Without a game ID we are not able to see into the ship and access the situation.


NaKraWedzi
Master Blacksmith

Posts: 25
Games: 53
Rank Points: 243
Member since: 2017-Nov-01

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Sep-30 14:51
https://game.thronemaster.net/?game=270112
Necrarch
Knight of Ni

Posts: 2,038
Games: 135
Rank Points: 1,003
Member since: 2019-Feb-01

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Sep-30 16:41
Seems to be a bug on the card implementation, Bara should have been forced to remove his units in the castles / strongholds instead of anywhere.

Could you create a Bug with the game link and your comments on it please ?

Tracker > New Case

Thanks for helping the game getting improved.


PhantasticPhil
Hand Of The King

Posts: 203
Games: 556
Rank Points: 4,306
Member since: 2016-Jun-23

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Sep-30 16:59
actually it is not a bug. The card says destroy 2 units at ONE of his castles, if that is not possible he has to destroy 2 units anywhere. As all his castles only held one unit, so there was no suitable castle and he can choose the units to destroy freely.


NaKraWedzi
Master Blacksmith

Posts: 25
Games: 53
Rank Points: 243
Member since: 2017-Nov-01

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Sep-30 17:09
Well, nice!
I guess you are right, errata had this question also!

Q: When resolving the penalty on “The Horde Descends”
Westeros card, can the two units that the lowest bidder must
destroy be from different areas?
A: No. All units that are destroyed must come from one
area with a castle/stronghold.

I guess losing control of 2 castles with single units would be too bad
PhantasticPhil
Hand Of The King

Posts: 203
Games: 556
Rank Points: 4,306
Member since: 2016-Jun-23

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Sep-30 17:51
I searched for it a few months back as well, because i also thought there was a bug.

Couldn't find the source again when i answered before


Necrarch
Knight of Ni

Posts: 2,038
Games: 135
Rank Points: 1,003
Member since: 2019-Feb-01

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Oct-01 09:22
Ah, well found, missed that! Thanks guys.



Please log in to use the reply function.
toast