Hello Community,

In the secrect chambers on this site, where we manage everything and discuss future developments, we got a contest "judge of the month" where we keep track who of us was the most diligent during the last month in resolving reports. We had a high rate of reports during the last months(265 in july and 228 in august), which is gladly decreasing atm.
But since everyone of you is only getting a message if his report was Resolved/Disregarded or if he just got sanctioned, we thought that you would appreciate an overview about the overall reports.

Because of this we decided too publish the following.
During the last 28 days we had:
178 New Reports
198 Reports have been resolved, of which 111 have been disregarded and 87 have been sanctioned(higher number is restload from more than 28 days)
6 of the resolved reports had an appeal and got reviewed again.
We wrote 365 comments on the reports(every report gets at least one comment before getting resolved)

This has been done by 8 (more or less active) judges.

Pls leave your impressions down below if you like this report(which we plan to do every month) and if you would like further information.

Last edited by Harakon on 2016-Sep-06 11:37, edited 1x in total

---

AFFC PBF - #10
You do not need to know everything, but where to read it.-Albert Einstein-

Reading is overrated.-sarcasm off-

Looks good to me!

Tremendous work guys!

178 new reports in a month, that's scary!

Keep up the good work!

---

Alea iacta est

111 of 198 reports disregarded...56% of reports.

Geez. Thanks for your work judges.

---

Thanks for the info and for your work!!

Thanks to all the judges (and especially to the anonymous "judge of the month" ) for all the efforts.

178 new reports in 28 days is a lot, indeed. From my point of view, even more shocking is the number of 111 out of 198 reports being disregarded (as Oursisthefury already pointed out).

What are these many unjustified reports based upon (allegations of kingmaking? Spoiling?)? Is there any way we can better explain the rules on this site so people know for sure, when to complain, and to thereby ensure you judges don't have to handle that many unjustified cases?

Last edited by obmit on 2016-Sep-07 09:36, edited 1x in total

I think often players make their own interpretation of reasons to report but also often it's very hard in this game to determine if actions are reportable. Not all players read/understand the rules/reasons to report to their full extent but it is out there.

We even got the amount of spoiling by stalling reports reduced to 0 due to the replacement thread (players get replaced and kicked if they're stalling) so that saves us alot of work.

If everyone would read the thread below we would have less disregarded reports, also they need to know the game/rules and the additional thronemaster.net rules.

https://www.thronemaster.net/?goto=community&sub=forum&fid=2&tid=17416#top

Often players have hunches about kingmaking/multi accounting/maintianing alliences cause it's not always obvious so we need to review games and check chatlogs to determine if rules were being broken. So there will always be reports who will be filed but disregarded and that's not a real problem imo, some of them are not much work, most work is to determine kingmaking accusations and debates with both reporters and reporteds.

---

Sorry if I didn't respond to your message(s), thats not intentional!

King of l.o.i.a.f. season 2 division 1
King of I.o.i.a.f. season 5 division 1

Wow, you guys are busy! Thank you for all the hard work.

Would it be possible to include the number of completed and aborted games in the report?

---

"If this is where the monarchy is headed, count me out! Out of service, out of Westeros, I wouldn't hang about." ~Ser Barristan Selmy

Thanks, guys!

---

"Kites rise highest against the wind - not with it."
- Winston Churchill

So many reports.. never thought that the numbers would be so high. Perhaps publishing these stats on a regular basis can help to raise the community awareness and improve their ethic on game! I imagine that any player is sensible when  faced with those.

One more time thanks a lot for your time spended and effort to keep this community healthy

My gratitude, peace everyone!

very useful I think.

---

Lord With honor and powerful army can defeat anyone.

As promised:

During the last 28 days we had:
167 New Reports
173 Reports have been resolved, of which 86 have been disregarded and 87 have been sanctioned(higher number is restload from more than 28 days)
1 of the resolved reports had an appeal and got reviewed again.
We wrote 311 comments on the reports(every report gets at least one comment before getting resolved)

The workload was a bit reduced and we had fewer reports, as our longterm statistics predicted.
Current Users in total: 10925(how many active users dont know)

During October we hope to bring out some automatic messages which should help especially newer players to find their way.
When will Wildling Cards come? Only JM Grip knows^^

Last edited by Harakon on 2016-Oct-01 17:57, edited 1x in total

---

AFFC PBF - #10
You do not need to know everything, but where to read it.-Albert Einstein-

Reading is overrated.-sarcasm off-

First time I see this thread. I must have been drunk for weeks!

During the last 28 days we had:
123 New Reports,128 Reports have been resolved, of which 77 have been disregarded and 51 have been sanctioned
1 of the resolved reports had an appeal and got reviewed again.
We wrote 206 comments on the reports(every report gets at least one comment before getting resolved)

The workload was a bit reduced and we had fewer reports, as our longterm statistics predicted.
Current Users in total: 11093(how many active users dont know)

During October we hope to bring out some automatic messages which should help especially newer players to find their way.
Actually I hoped to manage this myself but someone had to review all those reportsXD

Last edited by Harakon on 2016-Nov-03 10:12, edited 1x in total

---

AFFC PBF - #10
You do not need to know everything, but where to read it.-Albert Einstein-

Reading is overrated.-sarcasm off-

During the last 28 days we had:
107 New Reports
110 Reports have been resolved, of which 48 have been disregarded and 62 have been sanctioned(higher number is restload from more than 28 days)
2 of the resolved reports had an appeal and got reviewed again.
We wrote 196 comments on the reports(every report gets at least one comment before getting resolved)

The workload was a bit reduced and we had fewer reports, as our longterm statistics predicted.
Current Users in total: 11239 (how many active users I dont know)

With new features we are still waiting for our Lord an savior JM Grip. Maybe if we riot in the development forum or make him a christmas present we may finally convince him

At one time during the last week we were close to having no active report, butduring the last days you had some complaints

Last edited by Harakon on 2016-Nov-29 18:54, edited 1x in total

---

AFFC PBF - #10
You do not need to know everything, but where to read it.-Albert Einstein-

Reading is overrated.-sarcasm off-