Most users ever online was 263 on 2020-Apr-18 20:02
Users in total:
Newest user:
23 users online:
21,326
Klgany
Aidar 3 minutes ago

Soda create?

Aidar 38 minutes ago

Or create hostless plz

Aidar 42 minutes ago

Yes

fedda 43 minutes ago

why cant anyonee create..

Aidar 1 h 2 min ago

32 users online guys, let’s do live 3p

JamySistaBang 2 h 4 min ago

any new players?

Aidar 2 h 16 min ago

Amir create?

Aidar 2 h 19 min ago

Agreed

fedda 2 h 31 min ago

hate that im not a MoD haha

Aidar 3 hours ago

Create somebody

fedda 3 hours ago

down for live 3p

Aidar 4 hours ago

Live 3p fellas?

Blaan 9 hours ago

3p up

OberynM523 9 hours ago

3P LIVE?

ross58m 9 hours ago

criste we've started

OberynM523 10 hours ago

may any lord set up a new 3P rated live room?

OberynM523 10 hours ago

3P LIVE?

DaanSengers 13 hours ago

1p for 3p live

DaanSengers 13 hours ago

1p for 3p live

Wulf6 15 hours ago

quick 3player live up

I never asked for this.



Community Forum
Search |  


Author
Message
juliengreard
One Of The Kingsguard

Posts: 9
Games: 154
Rank Points: 920
Member since: 2013-May-01

Topic: Forced to retreat in port
Posted: 2020-Jul-23 23:39
Hello,

Here is my game :

https://game.thronemaster.net/?game=239560

I play Baratheon, I've been attacked in East Summer Sea and loose. I need to retreat 3 ships and the game automatically assumes I want to retreat them in the port of Sunspear. It's the "reasonable" choice as, otherwise, I would loose 1 ship but I don't see anywhere in the rules that I can't retreat in Shipbreaker Bay (and then loose 1 ship).

Can someone have a look and tell me if I'm correct ?

Thanks !

Julien


Necrarch
Knight of Ni

Posts: 2,108
Games: 138
Rank Points: 1,021
Member since: 2019-Feb-01

Topic: Forced to retreat in port
Posted: 2020-Jul-24 00:29
Bonsoir Julien,

Rules, page 21:

A player may not retreat his defending units to an area containing friendly units if this would cause him to exceed his Supply limit.

If a player’s only option is to retreat to such an area, he must first destroy as many retreating units as necessary to be compliant with his Supply limit after retreating to the area. After taking such losses, he may retreat the remaining units.

To sum up, you can never willingly remove a unit if you have an option allowing to save it, even if you end up in a worse situation.

I suppose this corresponds in the books/series to your poor defeated fleet fleeing for their lives for any place that would reduce immediate casualties - and possibly falling then into a trap.

To notice in your case that if your opponent had chosen a sworded card (e.g. Randyll instead of Mace), it would actually have been a better choice NOT to use Brienne to save your unit, in order to lose a ship and choose between two valid destinations.


juliengreard
One Of The Kingsguard

Posts: 9
Games: 154
Rank Points: 920
Member since: 2013-May-01

Topic: Forced to retreat in port
Posted: 2020-Jul-24 01:00
Ok thanks for the full answer !



Please log in to use the reply function.
toast