Most users ever online was 263 on 2020-Apr-18 20:02
Users in total:
Newest user:
21 users online:
21,868
Moriko
Daredevil Z 3 hours ago

2/3, one more to go

Daredevil Z 4 hours ago

3p fast

The Plumber from Asshai 9 hours ago

rated 3p anyone?

holtaf 11 hours ago

2/3

holtaf 11 hours ago

23

holtaf 11 hours ago

live 3p created, join up

SerOberynMartell 13 hours ago

omriex are you here?

SerOberynMartell 13 hours ago

Les sept couronnes waiting on you to ready up in live lobby

Soda-can 13 hours ago

One more! I'm hostage baby.

Soda-can 13 hours ago

3/6 LIVE

Soda-can 14 hours ago

It's really incredible to get to do this ²/6

Just do it 16 hours ago

3p live fast+

Daredevil Z 19 hours ago

3p live

CKyou2 20 hours ago

Ready?

CKyou2 20 hours ago

2/3

CKyou2 20 hours ago

1/3

Ihor 24 hours ago

2/3

Nicky 25 hours ago

Anyone 3p live?

Daredevil Z 27 hours ago

2/3

D_jaja 37 hours ago

5/6

I could have been an App ;-(



Community Forum
Search |  


Author
Message
erathirea
Battle Commander

Posts: 121
Games: 236
Rank Points: 1,312
Member since: 2019-Nov-13

Topic: Possible bug
Posted: 2020-May-27 12:14
Hi
Something odd happened in a recent game. I *think* it's a bug, but not sure.
https://game.thronemaster.net/?game=234625
In turn 8, as Lannister, I had taken Pyke. I then moved all my troops out of Pyke, forgetting that I would lose my ship in the port if I didn't leave a token behind.
What was odd is that not only did I lose the ship, but it immediately became a GJ ship. It didn't affect anything, as I moved back in later on turn 8, but just wondered if this was correct behaviour, or whether the ship should have died?
Additionally, I didn't remember there being a rule about "home" areas automatically returning to the "owner" if they are vacated without a power token being left behind - though I'd be happy to be proved wrong and can believe it.


Necrarch
Knight of Ni

Posts: 2,050
Games: 135
Rank Points: 1,003
Member since: 2019-Feb-01

Topic: Possible bug
Posted: 2020-May-27 12:37
No, the behaviour seems right.
If you leave the enemy home area without PT, the place returns automatically to its 'natural' owner, and the ships can return as well to him.

What can be discussable though:

- If the 'natural' owner should be left the choice between keeping or burning his ships when he gain them in port (could be better to destroy them if he knows the place will be retaken).

- And I think there is actually an issue I have seen in the game: if you leave an enemy home area with a fight (e.g. in your case you go to Seagard) without leaving a PT, you should, I think, not be able to retreat, as the place you left is no more yours to retreat to.
To sum up, if you leave no PT and lose the fight, then all your troops die automatically. Almost sure I did that once in a game (no idea when...) when baiting a card and managed to return to the capital safe.

-> Can someone around check the rules if this is precised, I am not fully sure of myself here and miss time ?
-> If yes, ask JM how it is implemented.

Thanks for your help!


erathirea
Battle Commander

Posts: 121
Games: 236
Rank Points: 1,312
Member since: 2019-Nov-13

Topic: Possible bug
Posted: 2020-May-27 14:58
Ah yes. Thanks, I just found that in the errata/FAQ. Interesting!


JM Grip
The 8th God

Posts: 5,236
Games: 92
Rank Points: 686
Member since: 2007-Sep-28

Topic: Possible bug
Posted: 2020-May-27 15:18
~closed~
~moved~


This Topic is closed.

Please log in to use the reply function.
toast