Most users ever online was 263 on 2020-Apr-18 20:02
Users in total:
Newest user:
17 users online:
20,373
DeeV
Rusername 2 h 19 min ago

how is it still beta?

Rusername 2 h 19 min ago

I remember when i used to play beta games here in 2022

Chirque 28 hours ago

2/3 live

Chirque 30 hours ago

3p live

Pith of House Meep Meep 35 hours ago

2/3 live

AhmdElonsndME2MarsRYvr- 40 hours ago

Thanks! 2 more!

amiramir 40 hours ago

create a game for you Ahmd?

p1tagora 42 hours ago

Casual 3p live is up

AhmdElonsndME2MarsRYvr- 44 hours ago

Yes, could that be name to?

fedda 44 hours ago

do u want 3 or 6?

AhmdElonsndME2MarsRYvr- 44 hours ago

Hello lovely people can anybody open a live for 3or6 which is unrated?

sebaleto 45 hours ago

3p live rated up. join

Lumpf 45 hours ago

2/3

Blaan 49 hours ago

2/3

Blaan 49 hours ago

3p up

sebaleto 50 hours ago

3p live up

Miaomiao! 52 hours ago

3P FAST

George Beselidze 55 hours ago

2/3 live

George Beselidze 56 hours ago

3p live up

Miaomiao! 61 hours ago

The another room the host isn't there

Think you are funny? Prove it!



Community Forum
Search |  


Author
Message
Ludens
Pawn

Posts: 1
Games: 0
Rank Points: 0
Member since: 2024-Sep-15

Topic: Salladhor Saan vs Victorian Greyjoy ship combat
Posted: 2024-Sep-15 18:09
If both house card abilities would activate, what will be the Greyjoy's ship's combat strenght at the end?
Necrarch
Knight of Ni

Posts: 2,215
Games: 141
Rank Points: 1,043
Member since: 2019-Feb-01

Topic: Salladhor Saan vs Victorian Greyjoy ship combat
Posted: 2024-Sep-15 19:40
Abilities activate in turn order on the IT track.

So if Greyjoy is before Baratheon, Victarion adds +1 to all ships then Salladhor reduces all to 0

The reverse way, Bara before, Salla reduces to 0, Victarion adds then +1 per ship.


NIghtCrawler
Master of War

Posts: 122
Games: 373
Rank Points: 2,621
Member since: 2020-May-27

Topic: Salladhor Saan vs Victorian Greyjoy ship combat
Posted: 2024-Sep-16 08:40
@Necrarch This is how it's supposed to be according to the rules, but we've tested it and the TM implementation is that Saladhor's ability always wins (meaning GJ's ships are always reduced to 0 strength).


Necrarch
Knight of Ni

Posts: 2,215
Games: 141
Rank Points: 1,043
Member since: 2019-Feb-01

Topic: Salladhor Saan vs Victorian Greyjoy ship combat
Posted: 2024-Sep-16 08:42
Ah, interesting point. I didn't know that, thanks for the clarification.
So it's badly implemented but most likely won't be fixed soon... sorry


Asha Blacktyde
Wardeness of the seas

Posts: 106
Games: 50
Rank Points: 202
Member since: 2024-Oct-25

Topic: Salladhor Saan vs Victorian Greyjoy ship combat
Posted: 2024-Nov-15 02:24
It is not ‘badly implemented’, it was just adapted to the rules of the original version before Fantasy Flight Games finally thought the rules update through after many, many rules requests and implemented it with the MoD add-on. See also for pretty much all reconsidered rule requests:

https://images-cdn.fantasyflightgames.com/filer_public/cf/06/cf06eb26-48e3-46b9-b57c-f053beb2518d/agotbg_faq_v2_forweb.pdf


Awesomo
Knight

Posts: 2
Games: 111
Rank Points: 585
Member since: 2021-Jun-30

Topic: Salladhor Saan vs Victorian Greyjoy ship combat
Posted: 2025-Jun-21 18:25
Ah, interesting point. I didn't know that, thanks for the clarification.
So it's badly implemented but most likely won't be fixed soon... sorry
I think it’s because with V’s ability, he can increase the ship battle power from 1 to 2, but not from 0 to 1. So if Salladhor’s ability goes first ie reducing down the power to 0, the condition from 1 to 2 doesn’t meet.

Please log in to use the reply function.
toast