Most users ever online was 263 on 2020-Apr-18 20:02
Users in total:
Newest user:
15 users online:
20,380
Zaldrizoti Qelbar
Miaomiao! 33 minutes ago

The another room the host isn't there

Miaomiao! 33 minutes ago

3p fast game come

Sir Garion 7 hours ago

3p up, come get some!

Sir Garion 7 hours ago

3p up

Lumpf 9 hours ago

2/3

lookkattme 11 hours ago

Any live 3p? >

amanwilldie 12 hours ago

3p live up!

Blaan 12 hours ago

2/3

Blaan 12 hours ago

3p up

Chirque 13 hours ago

2/3 live

Chirque 13 hours ago

3p live up

Lumpf 15 hours ago

Can anyone create a six player game pbem, please?

Soda-can 18 hours ago

mby ish bsv FART 2/3 BONN

Soda-can 21 hours ago

with the spirit what not to do and with no stand alone whos on the road to 7 with me ? liv6

Soda-can 22 hours ago

@Biorgnr U rock!

amanwilldie 28 hours ago

3p live up!

Soda-can 29 hours ago

one more ro start1

Soda-can 29 hours ago

well anyone for 3p win or die game?

Soda-can 31 hours ago

Got 'em screming pledin' for there savior, live holding on to meaning 2/6 /-

snufkin_1301 32 hours ago

+1 3pl live

The King shits, the Hand whipes...



Community Forum
Search |  


Author
Message
PMeisterGeneral
One Of The Kingsguard

Posts: 124
Games: 180
Rank Points: 959
Member since: 2019-Apr-27

Topic: Lannister - 7 Castle analysis
Posted: 2021-Oct-16 17:10
So for the next installment of my 7 Castle analysis series (long awaited I hope!) we're looking at one of the hardest and most interesting houses to play - the lannisters.

Arguably the only house able to reasonably challenge the targaryens in the incest league the lannisters are very unforgiving in the hands of a new (or drunk!) player with a steep learning curve.

So without further ado:

Lannisport and riverrun - 50/50 - 100%
Harrenhal - 46/50 - 92%
Seagard - 38/50 - 76%
Pyke - 29/50 - 58%
Flints finger - 27/50 - 54%
Crackclaw point - 26/50 - 52%
The reach - 24/50 - 48%
Moat cailin - 18/50 - 36%
Kings landing - 17/50 - 34%
Highgarden - 12/50 - 24%
Oldtown - 6/50 - 12%
White Harbour - 3/50 - 6%
Winterfel - 2/50 - 4%
Sunspear and starfall - 1/50 - 2% (you absolute mad lad well done!)


Nomaris
Maester without a chain

Posts: 2,610
Games: 410
Rank Points: 2,739
Member since: 2017-May-19

Topic: Lannister - 7 Castle analysis
Posted: 2021-Oct-16 17:23
Great analysis! Thank you!

Except for Sunspear and Starfall this is exactly as I would suspect it:

Best chances for a 7 castle Lanni win are against Greyjoy + Moat Cailin, followed by combinations against Bara and Tyrell.


PMeisterGeneral
One Of The Kingsguard

Posts: 124
Games: 180
Rank Points: 959
Member since: 2019-Apr-27

Topic: Lannister - 7 Castle analysis
Posted: 2021-Oct-16 19:30
Thanks nomaris, just my little low tech attempt to build and deepen the body of theory behind this game

Key takeaways are that greyjoy are your primary route to victory followed by baratheon and tyrell in that order. Most of these games ended with greyjoy almost entirely wiped out.


PMeisterGeneral
One Of The Kingsguard

Posts: 124
Games: 180
Rank Points: 959
Member since: 2019-Apr-27

Topic: Lannister - 7 Castle analysis
Posted: 2021-Oct-16 21:53
Couple more points on reflection:

More than half these wins require a conquest of greyjoy.

Tyrell should be more afraid of you than you of tyrell (they might QoT stony Sept but they won't end the game controlling your castles).

Once we hit the middle game we should have 3 stony septs: the original stony Sept but also harrenhal (if you are above baratheon on the iron throne (worth it despite super stannis) and control Blackwater (which you should) a raid from Blackwater to crackclaw makes harrenhal unreadable support) and eventually ironmans Bay.

Just like tyrell ironmans Bay is your meal ticket. While tyrell are only your 3rd best prospect to conquer you will want the same areas so be on guard. Based on my tyrell analysis lannister is 5 times more likely to conquer tyrell than vice versa.

Never forget ironmans Bay is to you what the narrow sea is to baratheon. Early game to paraphrase yoda in attack of the clones

"around stony Sept, a perimeter create" with your midgame objectives being to prepare to backstab greyjoy and lock down either ironmans or harrenhal as a 2nd unraidable support hub.

If you manage to get all 3 you really should be winning this game bar a timely Web of lies.


Necrarch
Knight of Ni

Posts: 2,215
Games: 141
Rank Points: 1,043
Member since: 2019-Feb-01

Topic: Lannister - 7 Castle analysis
Posted: 2021-Oct-16 22:27
One surprise I see is that none of the Lannis above has taken the Eyrié, which is NOT a bad plan if you manage to get a control on CCP. Thanks for the analysis, great one.


Ser Hodor
Son Of Hodor

Posts: 758
Games: 1,358
Rank Points: 10,286
Member since: 2016-Mar-20

Topic: Lannister - 7 Castle analysis
Posted: 2021-Oct-22 22:24
The Eyrie is 2 steps away from CCP, which is already outside Lanni's secure perimeter. Getting an army there while exposed to enemy sea support/transport is practically impossible.
PMeisterGeneral
One Of The Kingsguard

Posts: 124
Games: 180
Rank Points: 959
Member since: 2019-Apr-27

Topic: Lannister - 7 Castle analysis
Posted: 2021-Oct-23 13:05
One thing I was surprised at was how often baratheon castles show up given the constant sea support from shipbreaker and Blackwater bay. I suspect these were the last castles taken before baratheon could recapture.


Nomaris
Maester without a chain

Posts: 2,610
Games: 410
Rank Points: 2,739
Member since: 2017-May-19

Topic: Lannister - 7 Castle analysis
Posted: 2021-Oct-23 13:47
Or sea support was countered by HH and/or BW support.


PMeisterGeneral
One Of The Kingsguard

Posts: 124
Games: 180
Rank Points: 959
Member since: 2019-Apr-27

Topic: Lannister - 7 Castle analysis
Posted: 2021-Oct-23 15:34
I think harrenhal is the key, once you take ccp harrenhal becomes your second stony Sept. I think its importance is slept on maybe because it 'only' supports 4 territories but those 4 territories are stony Sept, riverrun ccp and Blackwater - all lynch pins of lannisters game.



Please log in to use the reply function.
toast