THRONEMASTER.NET - Game Of Thrones / The Boardgame Network

Most users ever online was 263 on 2020-Apr-18 20:02
Users in total: Newest user: 38 users online:	24,285 Rafs14 Arbar \| Arunamaru \| Ashoka_79 \| Boromirinder \| Borson \| Ccbaby \| Clockwork \| Darkstar1 \| Defglobal \| diamonnd \| diogobensabat \| Drik \| El Grande \| Fungfung \| Icyg00s3 \| Jachu \| Johnny_Gen \| Kliasmlias \| LisanAlGahib \| orham2 \| purplecloud1985 \| RodrigoLannister \| Romella \| ryder121 \| Smittytothebbc \| Stachu \| Strongest_Gallic \| TheMoth \| Tobynator8 \| Venge \| Winther020798 \| yangtaojun \| YwoR \| zaky920 \| zhanghe \| Zoumba \|

Most users ever online was 263 on 2020-Apr-18 20:02

Users in total:
Newest user:
38 users online:

Der Seynmaster	7 minutes ago
@maumastoks: Did you really blacklist me? @everyone else: will he be able to read this message if I‘m on his blacklist?

BOSSShark	21 minutes ago
3p live pls

YouDontKnowJack	1 h 14 min ago
HELLO

logos	4 hours ago
2/3

logos	4 hours ago
1/3

LisanAlGahib	7 hours ago
tiguera rejoin

Tiguera	7 hours ago
2/3

LisanAlGahib	8 hours ago
4p up

LisanAlGahib	8 hours ago
4p up

neonek	10 hours ago
live 3p up

jackpearson870817	10 hours ago
Any MOT helps to create a live 6p game, better with house selection, thanks a lot.

Madoxx	17 hours ago
3 fast

SansaLydia	17 hours ago
2/3

SansaLydia	17 hours ago
3P Live Rated Fast++ Come on Lord

Sigi Reuven	18 hours ago
I aborted my 3p by mistake, come rejoin

SansaLydia	19 hours ago
3P Live Rated Fast++ Come on Lord

Tore2	20 hours ago
2/3

maumastoks	20 hours ago
6p pbem rated europe fast+ created

SansaLydia	21 hours ago
2/3

SansaLydia	21 hours ago
3P Live Rated Fast++ Come on Lord

Hail to JM Grip!

Community Forum

Forums > Help Forum / Rules Questions / FAQ > Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!

Search |

1 2 3 4 567 8

Author

Message

JM Grip
^{The 8th God}

Posts: 5,224
Games: 92
Rank Points: 686
Member since: 2007-Sep-28

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2017-Feb-15 10:11

What do you want to tell us?

- What do we say to New Features? Not Today.

alexk
^{Master Blacksmith}

Posts: 44
Games: 69
Rank Points: 296
Member since: 2017-Jan-09

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2017-Feb-15 13:58

That was a reply to Claesar's post

I explained why the implementation of the one-combat-per-march rule agrees with the rule book. I edited my previous post to make it more understandable.

cipo
^Knight

Posts: 1
Games: 207
Rank Points: 528
Member since: 2017-Feb-27

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2017-Mar-10 09:48

oook

I am I

Visara
^Knight

Posts: 185
Games: 220
Rank Points: 674
Member since: 2016-Jul-10

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2017-Sep-22 02:36

Ok, a bit far-fetched but true:

The option to use the sword only pops-up when it makes a difference in the battle outcome, right?
In very, very rare cases the holder of the sword may be afraid that Martell will steal the sword from him at a later point in the round with Doran Martell. To make sure that Martell doesn't obtain an unused sword it can be a smart idea to use to sword even if it doesn't change the outcome of the battle.
At the real boardgame that's possible, here it isn't. (And I am happy to keep it as it is

)

We buy stuff we don't need, with money we don't have, to impress people we don't like.

JM Grip
^{The 8th God}

Posts: 5,224
Games: 92
Rank Points: 686
Member since: 2007-Sep-28

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2017-Sep-22 09:52

A known issue, but I wouldn't want the game to ask everytime because of this very special case. Also the logging would need some changes.

Nevertheless something for our todo list.

- What do we say to New Features? Not Today.

NomNomNom
^Squire

Posts: 5
Games: 71
Rank Points: 370
Member since: 2017-May-23

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2018-Aug-07 15:59

Hi, I just noticed in the middle of the main post the line:
"- There are no 'Tides of Battle' cards." ( right at the end of the 1st set of rules)
I guess this was written before implementing them?

Harakon
^{Grandmaester of Reports}

Posts: 3,634
Games: 903
Rank Points: 3,430
Member since: 2014-Aug-24

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2018-Aug-07 17:34

That was correct^^

AFFC PBF - #10
You do not need to know everything, but where to read it.-Albert Einstein-

Reading is overrated.-sarcasm off-

nimilem
^{Stonemason's Apprentice}

Posts: 1
Games: 12
Rank Points: 23
Member since: 2019-Jun-06

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2019-Jun-12 11:48

what is the penalty if i were kicked out from a live game?

Lannie85
^{Protector Of The Realm}

Posts: 6,063
Games: 871
Rank Points: 6,222
Member since: 2014-Feb-25

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2019-Jun-12 12:09

what is the penalty if i were kicked out from a live game?
1st kick 12 hour automatic join ban, the more you get kicked, the longer your ban gets.

Sorry if I didn't respond to your message(s), thats not intentional!

King of l.o.i.a.f. season 2 division 1
King of I.o.i.a.f. season 5 division 1

Shadowleaves
^{Master Blacksmith}

Posts: 1
Games: 73
Rank Points: 281
Member since: 2020-Mar-01

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2020-Mar-09 05:29

hi i guess you may already know but wildlings bug when at 12, they just don't attack. Is there a way to fix this while in the game ?

Not all those who wander are lost

Harakon
^{Grandmaester of Reports}

Posts: 3,634
Games: 903
Rank Points: 3,430
Member since: 2014-Aug-24

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2020-Mar-09 07:55

Known but not a bug in the meaning. Since intentional 1st Edition rule.

AFFC PBF - #10
You do not need to know everything, but where to read it.-Albert Einstein-

Reading is overrated.-sarcasm off-

Vasiliy
^Stonemason

Posts: 8
Games: 21
Rank Points: 34
Member since: 2020-Mar-29

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2020-Mar-30 00:17

Hi. I am new here. And have one question abount tie breaking.

I read this topic and saw this:

- Tie breaker in the end
If you do NOT explicitly choose the Second Edition Tie Breaker option, the following text explains who will win the game on a tie:
When after the 10th turn nobody met the instant winning condition, the tie is NOT broken by the number of strongholds (large castles). The order is:
1) Number of areas containing a stronghold or a castle
2) Position on the supply track
3) Amount of power tokens
4) Position on the Iron Throne track

In my game that tie breaker wasn't chosen. This is the log:

https://game.thronemaster.net/?game=226085&show=log

In the end of game Greyjoy and Stark each had 5 castles and strongholds (no diffs as I understood). Grey had 4 supply, while Stark has only 3. But Stark won. Could you explain, what I missed in rules so that situation happened?

JM Grip
^{The 8th God}

Posts: 5,224
Games: 92
Rank Points: 686
Member since: 2007-Sep-28

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2020-Mar-30 08:16

We recently changed the default setup for new games. so that part is outdated.

- What do we say to New Features? Not Today.

Vasiliy
^Stonemason

Posts: 8
Games: 21
Rank Points: 34
Member since: 2020-Mar-29

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2020-Mar-30 15:33

So how it works now? Nobody understood it in the game.

JM Grip
^{The 8th God}

Posts: 5,224
Games: 92
Rank Points: 686
Member since: 2007-Sep-28

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2020-Mar-30 15:47

https://www.thronemaster.net/?goto=gaming&sub=help#2nd_tie_breaker2019

updated the first post

- What do we say to New Features? Not Today.

1 2 3 4 567 8

Please log in to use the reply function.