THRONEMASTER.NET - Game Of Thrones / The Boardgame Network

Most users ever online was 263 on 2020-Apr-18 20:02
Users in total: Newest user: 30 users online:	21,942 wxcs0001 Ajax_berik1 \| Alucasrd \| Bonaventure \| diogobensabat \| Eli Cash \| ENesbit \| Freyeik \| gdpmusique \| geolem \| House Blaies \| JaqenHghar0 \| JohnnyCee \| juniornog82 \| LisanAlGahib \| NIghtCrawler \| Pazifist \| rallysm \| Ramoin \| samofdorne \| Sean_Snow \| Shaun Baun \| summer has come \| The Plumber from Asshai \| Vacho \| yangtao \|

aicemxxice	1 h 39 min ago
need 3live fast room

Lord Crook	5 hours ago
Sorry accidentally aborted

Lord Crook	5 hours ago
3 up

Phobey	8 hours ago
2/3 live up

Phobey	8 hours ago
2/3

Phobey	8 hours ago
3p live up

D_jaja	11 hours ago
3p live up

sydneygas	13 hours ago
one more needed for war

sydneygas	17 hours ago
why not!

Nicky	17 hours ago
Anyone 3p live?

lilbills	21 hours ago
2/3

Kaka8Miranda	22 hours ago
Any MOT around got 3 guys who want to play live

gb730320	23 hours ago
3p fast

Strongest_Gallic	25 hours ago
@Nightcrawler: for beginners it’s good to create 3p games. They go faster and it’s therefore more fun to learn how to play

Highlander55	27 hours ago
Need a replacement for a rated game. Greyjoiy, T8, good position. Visit the forum in the replacement section.

omriex7	35 hours ago
3p live 2/3

Les sept couronnes	37 hours ago
New game live please

NIghtCrawler	37 hours ago
I created some blue beginners games that more people can join!

Taxodium	37 hours ago
beginner game still need 2 players seemingly

Les sept couronnes	38 hours ago
One more please

Take sec and thank our team!

Community Forum

Forums > Help Forum / Rules Questions / FAQ > Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!

Search |

1 234 5 6 7 8

Author

Message

Strongest_Gallic
^{King's Councillor}

Posts: 586
Games: 382
Rank Points: 3,001
Member since: 2015-Jun-01

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2015-Nov-30 15:50

I was trying to find something in the rules and came on to this:

If, during the Resolve Consolidate Power Orders step of the Action Phase, there are enemy ships in the sea area connected to a port, any Consolidate Power Order assigned to the Port
is removed without effect. Otherwise, a Consolidate Power Order in a Port is resolved normally (as if it was in a land area containing no Power icons).

As far as I know this is not (yet) a feature in the online game?

If I understand well, this would mean in a 6p game that for example the port of storms end is almost useless to martell?

‘Cause Caesar said so…

nils
^{Royal wedding planner}

Posts: 265
Games: 81
Rank Points: 210
Member since: 2014-Oct-24

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2015-Nov-30 16:15

Raiding or supporting from the port of storm ends is usefull for me.

Strongest_Gallic
^{King's Councillor}

Posts: 586
Games: 382
Rank Points: 3,001
Member since: 2015-Jun-01

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2015-Nov-30 16:52

Ofcourse, I misformulated that, but I am right this is a rule only for the board game?

‘Cause Caesar said so…

poncho
^{One Of The Kingsguard}

Posts: 1,729
Games: 90
Rank Points: 878
Member since: 2009-Jul-09

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2015-Nov-30 17:13

No, as far as I know this is already implemented on the site. So yes, Martell cannot consolidate in the port of Storm's End if Baratheon has a ship in Shipbreaker Bay.

You probably mean round, not turn. There's a difference.

KronusPL
^Stonemason

Posts: 133
Games: 30
Rank Points: 46
Member since: 2015-Nov-08

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2015-Dec-15 09:14

why is player elimination not mentioned here? why is it even implemented?

JM Grip
^{The 8th God}

Posts: 5,236
Games: 92
Rank Points: 686
Member since: 2007-Sep-28

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2015-Dec-15 11:07

player elimination[...]
why is it even implemented?
There were no PBEM mode in the beginning of this site. And in LIVE games it's makes sense to implement such a thing, because players intent to leave if there is no chance of winning anyway.

- What do we say to New Features? Not Today.

Duesterwald
^{Faceless Man}

Posts: 2,604
Games: 102
Rank Points: 441
Member since: 2013-Mar-21

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2015-Dec-15 11:51

why is player elimination not mentioned here?
Added.

KronusPL
^Stonemason

Posts: 133
Games: 30
Rank Points: 46
Member since: 2015-Nov-08

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2015-Dec-15 13:46

I understand player elimination after leaving/being kicked, but I don't understand the reasons for it when all player has left is ships or even no units. There is still power tokens and always a chance his home territory is liberated.

Last edited by KronusPL on 2015-Dec-15 13:46, edited 1x in total

KronusPL
^Stonemason

Posts: 133
Games: 30
Rank Points: 46
Member since: 2015-Nov-08

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2015-Dec-15 13:47

Also please add the player elimination proccess after being kicked - orders changed into defense, land units being neutral forces

Duesterwald
^{Faceless Man}

Posts: 2,604
Games: 102
Rank Points: 441
Member since: 2013-Mar-21

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2015-Dec-15 15:40

@KronusPL: thanks for the suggestion

KronusPL
^Stonemason

Posts: 133
Games: 30
Rank Points: 46
Member since: 2015-Nov-08

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2015-Dec-15 20:23

@Duesterwald
If a player gets kicked, all the orders will turn into Defense Orders, and all units become neutral units. The Defense Orders are removed at the next end of turn.
Support Orders change into Def, maybe Marches too, I don't know in what priority.
Consolidate Power Orders don't change - might be relevant info if player is replaced later after initial kick for example.
Also I thought the Def Orders are removed at the end of the same turn - the round after elimination there is no orders placed from eliminated player, is there?

derBleede
^{Master Blacksmith}

Posts: 377
Games: 115
Rank Points: 246
Member since: 2014-Mar-24

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2015-Dec-15 21:22

- the round after elimination there is no orders placed from eliminated player, is there?
no there are not, as your quote says: they are removed at the next end of turn (not at the end of next turn - word order

)

KronusPL
^Stonemason

Posts: 133
Games: 30
Rank Points: 46
Member since: 2015-Nov-08

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2015-Dec-16 10:15

the word 'next' is therefore obsolete and confusing.

is supporting other players against neutral forces implemented? if not, please mention it

Duesterwald
^{Faceless Man}

Posts: 2,604
Games: 102
Rank Points: 441
Member since: 2013-Mar-21

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2015-Dec-16 10:32

Consolidate Power Orders don't change
How about Raid Orders? Does anyone know?

is supporting other players against neutral forces implemented?
AFAIK it is not implemented yet. Will add it.

Maybe we should have given you edit rights for that post, Kronus

KronusPL
^Stonemason

Posts: 133
Games: 30
Rank Points: 46
Member since: 2015-Nov-08

Topic: Differences between 2nd Edition and this version here?!
Posted: 2015-Dec-16 10:44

haha maybe.

I think Raid orders disappear.

edit:
I reviewed a game where a player was kicked, raid disappeared because it was raided even before the kick, and you were right, CP are also changed into Def order. What I would like to know is what happens when there is Marches, Support and CP orders - are all change to def +1 orders, even though normally you only have 2, or what is the priority?

https://game.thronemaster.net/?review=1&game=62045

Last edited by KronusPL on 2015-Dec-16 10:47, edited 1x in total

1 234 5 6 7 8

Please log in to use the reply function.