It is good idea i think 
. It is good soluttion for problems with orders.
. It is good soluttion for problems with orders.
| Most users ever online was 263 on 2020-Apr-18 20:02 | |
| Users in total: Newest user: 45 users online: | 21,835 MaChaa _JAP_ |
 abbadon123 |
AnusVoador |
BlackwaterRush |
Bohu |
Cal27 |
Davide_P |
diogobensabat |
Dr_samdrew |
Fisher_S |
gdpmusique |
geolem |
Ice-chan |
Jakubesh |
JaqenHghar0 |
jonnysucksnot |
juniornog82 |
KIM-REIN |
koulis13 |
Krolson |
LisanAlGahib |
machieO |
Mad King |
MegaMaster |
Meli7 |
Micky McBackyStabby |
Morringotto |
NIghtCrawler |
Patrek Harlow |
purplecloud1985 |
Reaper |
Shade89 |
SirRoger |
squallwst |
summer has come |
Sundong |
SyrioForel |
TheRose27 |
ZCR8899 |
zhazhayu |
Zorander |
|
|---|---|
| Daredevil Z | 2 h 43 min ago |
|---|---|
2/3 | |
| Daredevil Z | 3 hours ago |
|---|---|
2/3 | |
| Mad King | 4 hours ago |
|---|---|
cant see the game unfortunatly | |
| omriex7 | 4 hours ago |
|---|---|
6p live come join | |
| Mad King | 4 hours ago |
|---|---|
anyone up for a 6p live fast? | |
| omriex7 | 5 hours ago |
|---|---|
3p live 2/3 | |
| eilon53 | 7 hours ago |
|---|---|
2/3 live | |
| travis23 | 9 hours ago |
|---|---|
3p live's up | |
| Daredevil Z | 11 hours ago |
|---|---|
3p fast, welcome | |
| First Sword of Braavos | 11 hours ago |
|---|---|
2/3 | |
| First Sword of Braavos | 11 hours ago |
|---|---|
Sad this game is less popular these days | |
| Kamil14 | 14 hours ago |
|---|---|
If they don't controll any castles/strongholds and have units, then they still participate in bidding | |
| Kamil14 | 14 hours ago |
|---|---|
They are in the game as long as they have at least one land unit. | |
| The Sphinx | 15 hours ago |
|---|---|
If a player possess 0 castles or strongholds and a clash comes, are they able to bid the tracks? | |
| Sean_Snow | 15 hours ago |
|---|---|
And that's how Dusteppe became a turncoat | |
| Sean_Snow | 15 hours ago |
|---|---|
And rhapsody how Dusteppe became a turncoat | |
| Sean_Snow | 15 hours ago |
|---|---|
And rhapsody how Dusteppe became a turncoat | |
| holtaf | 16 hours ago |
|---|---|
There's no way to cancel if you had pressed proceed | |
| dusteppe | 17 hours ago |
|---|---|
Is it possible to cancel an attack after clicking proceed? I clicked the wrong region by accident | |
| zbh711 | 17 hours ago |
|---|---|
2/3 | |
I never asked for this.
Author
Message
I want to pick a the "Road" topic again:
How should we handle roads (Goldroad, Kingsroad, Roseroad)? Should they provide a little extra benefit?
Question I:
Should we keep a mechanism which is based on gaining power token?
[A] yes
[B] no
Question II:
If we keep the mechanism of gaining power token, how should it be handled?
[A] You gain a power token during Game of Thrones, when you have established control over the area with a power token or an unit inside
[B] You gain a power token during Game of Thrones, only when you have a unit inside the area
Question III:
If we decide not the keep the power token based mechanism, what other solution should we implement?
[A] No additional mechanism, keep the rules simple
[B] You can take your march order into that area, when its empty and it does not come to a fight, the mechanism would represent the faster movement on roads (we would have to clarify, if the moved march has to be executed at once or not, to avoid delay tactics)
[C] Units of different players can stay within the same area (further rule clarification would be needed), it would represent that is must not come to a fight on roads
[D] Other suggestion
How should we handle roads (Goldroad, Kingsroad, Roseroad)? Should they provide a little extra benefit?
Question I:
Should we keep a mechanism which is based on gaining power token?
[A] yes
[B] no
Question II:
If we keep the mechanism of gaining power token, how should it be handled?
[A] You gain a power token during Game of Thrones, when you have established control over the area with a power token or an unit inside
[B] You gain a power token during Game of Thrones, only when you have a unit inside the area
Question III:
If we decide not the keep the power token based mechanism, what other solution should we implement?
[A] No additional mechanism, keep the rules simple
[B] You can take your march order into that area, when its empty and it does not come to a fight, the mechanism would represent the faster movement on roads (we would have to clarify, if the moved march has to be executed at once or not, to avoid delay tactics)
[C] Units of different players can stay within the same area (further rule clarification would be needed), it would represent that is must not come to a fight on roads
[D] Other suggestion
~ A Lannister Always Pays His Debts
Question I:
[A] yes
Question II:
I would say a combination of both [A] and [B]; you can gain the token if you have a unit present and/or have a power token in the road area. This method would not strictly mean that the area behaves as though it has a crown symbol since any CP orders placed would only generate 1 token at the end of the turn.
Question III:
[B] sounds interesting, however, perhaps extend it so that even if you have a unit already in the area you can take the march order with you provided that there is not already an order in that area?
[C] might work but could raise difficulties during the planning phase, how supply is calculated, whether units of different Houses can take advantage of orders attached to units of other House in those areas, and retreating
[A] yes
Question II:
I would say a combination of both [A] and [B]; you can gain the token if you have a unit present and/or have a power token in the road area. This method would not strictly mean that the area behaves as though it has a crown symbol since any CP orders placed would only generate 1 token at the end of the turn.
Question III:
[B] sounds interesting, however, perhaps extend it so that even if you have a unit already in the area you can take the march order with you provided that there is not already an order in that area?
[C] might work but could raise difficulties during the planning phase, how supply is calculated, whether units of different Houses can take advantage of orders attached to units of other House in those areas, and retreating
Question II:
I would say a combination of both [A] and [B]; you can gain the token if you have a unit present and/or have a power token in the road area. This method would not strictly mean that the area behaves as though it has a crown symbol since any CP orders placed would only generate 1 token at the end of the turn.
Answer [A] was meant like that. I clarify the answer a bit.
I would say a combination of both [A] and [B]; you can gain the token if you have a unit present and/or have a power token in the road area. This method would not strictly mean that the area behaves as though it has a crown symbol since any CP orders placed would only generate 1 token at the end of the turn.
Answer [A] was meant like that. I clarify the answer a bit.
~ A Lannister Always Pays His Debts
1B
2B
3B
In 3B better you can take road an if you want continue with march you can imidiatly but you must need leave here one unit.
And what you think about special raid order? Im think it will be more powerfull if you can use special raid orders before clasic raids.
2B
3B
In 3B better you can take road an if you want continue with march you can imidiatly but you must need leave here one unit.
And what you think about special raid order? Im think it will be more powerfull if you can use special raid orders before clasic raids.
In 3B better you can take road an if you want continue with march you can imidiatly but you must need leave here one unit.
Good idea! That would make these marches not to powerful.
And what you think about special raid order? Im think it will be more powerfull if you can use special raid orders before clasic raids. I think that would make the Kingscourt track stronger compared to the Ironthron track. I dont like the idea.
~ A Lannister Always Pays His Debts
OursistheFury
Lord Paramount of the Stormlands
Lord Paramount of the Stormlands
Posts: 849
Games: 522
Rank Points: 3,555
Member since: 2013-Sep-23
I really like the idea of accelerated movement in these areas, but there are simply too few of them to be able to implement this. If a march could be carried into the area then it should come at a cost. The idea of having to leave a unit behind could work.
The Road areas cannot however both enhance movement and provide power tokens though -- that would be too OP. It should be one or the other.
So, if we stick with power tokens:
1A
2B
3A
And if we change the function to movement:
1B
2 none
3B, but with restrictions
The Road areas cannot however both enhance movement and provide power tokens though -- that would be too OP. It should be one or the other.
So, if we stick with power tokens:
1A
2B
3A
And if we change the function to movement:
1B
2 none
3B, but with restrictions
The idea of having to leave a unit behind could work.
What about lowering the power of the march order? if you have a march+1 order, it turns in a march+0 order once carried on the road. if you have a march+0 order, it turns in a march -1 order, and lastly, if you have a march -1 order, it turns in a march -2.
This way you can represent the fatigue of the double march.
just my two cents. sorry everyone for the disturb.
Radagast
What about lowering the power of the march order? if you have a march+1 order, it turns in a march+0 order once carried on the road. if you have a march+0 order, it turns in a march -1 order, and lastly, if you have a march -1 order, it turns in a march -2.
This way you can represent the fatigue of the double march.
just my two cents. sorry everyone for the disturb.
Radagast