THRONEMASTER.NET - Game Of Thrones / The Boardgame Network

Most users ever online was 263 on 2020-Apr-18 20:02
Users in total: Newest user: 43 users online:	21,945 mab-de1 Ariongalahat \| bigchiefs \| Bohu \| Davide_P \| Deadnostrillicaeroz \| diogobensabat \| evgen0111 \| fantazm \| Figueira \| Flavioncho \| Freyeik \| Fuego Domato \| Guiscard \| Huberto \| Icarium \| JaqenHghar0 \| laosiji \| lcx666 \| Les sept couronnes \| Lord Underwall \| machieO \| Meli7 \| Necrarch \| Nero \| newMDKiller \| NIghtCrawler \| PawcioF \| Podrick Pain \| Reaper \| Reqinek \| Rustali23 \| Saizzo \| samofdorne \| SirRoger \| sydneygas \| Taxodium \| Vacho \| Veit \| vyacheslav \| Vydra \|

Most users ever online was 263 on 2020-Apr-18 20:02

Users in total:
Newest user:
43 users online:

Les sept couronnes	37 minutes ago
4player live free choice please

sydneygas	56 minutes ago
one more needed

sydneygas	1 h 7 min ago
3p live is up

JonArryn	1 h 25 min ago
WC 2024 SF 19 did not start, the game expired

lilbills	1 h 28 min ago
up for a 3p

Taxodium	2 h 0 min ago
Thank you very much

PawcioF	2 h 7 min ago
read this thread. You can join beginner games (green)

PawcioF	2 h 7 min ago
https://www.thronemaster.net/?goto=community&sub=forum&fid=1&tid=4512#top

Taxodium	2 h 9 min ago
Oh，I am a new users and i have some language problem,I want to know how to start a game quickly,what can i do.Thx

Chrollo	2 h 13 min ago
What do you need Freshman

Taxodium	2 h 16 min ago
Did anyone can help a freshman

lilbills	2 h 29 min ago
ah missed it bummer

lilbills	2 h 30 min ago
not seeing it

almightychris	2 h 33 min ago
3p up

lilbills	2 h 35 min ago
id be down

Nicky	2 h 36 min ago
Anyone 3p live?

lilbills	3 hours ago
up for a live

gb730320	7 hours ago
3p fast

D_jaja	14 hours ago
3p live up

D_jaja	18 hours ago
3p live up

Don't talk down to me.

Community Forum

Forums > Help Forum / Rules Questions / FAQ > Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships

Search |

Author

Message

NaKraWedzi
^{Master Blacksmith}

Posts: 25
Games: 53
Rank Points: 243
Member since: 2017-Nov-01

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Sep-30 13:57

Hello,
recently in my game we lost with wildlings with card The Horde Descends.
Baratheon was considered lowest bider and he had to:
"Baratheon has to destroy 2 units at one of his Castles or Strongholds instead of 1 unit anywhere."
and he destroyed ships in Blackwater Bay.
Should it be allowed? He can muster ships there, so it counts as a castle area? I will add that he had land units available.

Harakon
^{Grandmaester of Reports}

Posts: 3,634
Games: 903
Rank Points: 3,430
Member since: 2014-Aug-24

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Sep-30 14:05

Hi NaKraWedzi

Without a game ID we are not able to see into the ship and access the situation.

AFFC PBF - #10
You do not need to know everything, but where to read it.-Albert Einstein-

Reading is overrated.-sarcasm off-

NaKraWedzi
^{Master Blacksmith}

Posts: 25
Games: 53
Rank Points: 243
Member since: 2017-Nov-01

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Sep-30 14:51

https://game.thronemaster.net/?game=270112

Necrarch
^{Knight of Ni}

Posts: 2,045
Games: 135
Rank Points: 1,003
Member since: 2019-Feb-01

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Sep-30 16:41

Seems to be a bug on the card implementation, Bara should have been forced to remove his units in the castles / strongholds instead of anywhere.

Could you create a Bug with the game link and your comments on it please ?

Tracker > New Case

Thanks for helping the game getting improved.

Judge
LoI&F: Seasons 10 and 11 King
France WCup team
2021: Bronze
2022: Silver

PhantasticPhil
^{Hand Of The King}

Posts: 204
Games: 557
Rank Points: 4,306
Member since: 2016-Jun-23

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Sep-30 16:59

actually it is not a bug. The card says destroy 2 units at ONE of his castles, if that is not possible he has to destroy 2 units anywhere. As all his castles only held one unit, so there was no suitable castle and he can choose the units to destroy freely.

Last edited by PhantasticPhil on 2021-Sep-30 17:03, edited 1x in total

Mother of Dragons PBF #1 – Arryn

NaKraWedzi
^{Master Blacksmith}

Posts: 25
Games: 53
Rank Points: 243
Member since: 2017-Nov-01

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Sep-30 17:09

Well, nice!
I guess you are right, errata had this question also!

Q: When resolving the penalty on “The Horde Descends”
Westeros card, can the two units that the lowest bidder must
destroy be from different areas?
A: No. All units that are destroyed must come from one
area with a castle/stronghold.

I guess losing control of 2 castles with single units would be too bad

PhantasticPhil
^{Hand Of The King}

Posts: 204
Games: 557
Rank Points: 4,306
Member since: 2016-Jun-23

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Sep-30 17:51

I searched for it a few months back as well, because i also thought there was a bug.

Couldn't find the source again when i answered before

Mother of Dragons PBF #1 – Arryn

Necrarch
^{Knight of Ni}

Posts: 2,045
Games: 135
Rank Points: 1,003
Member since: 2019-Feb-01

Topic: Wildlings attack, The Horde Descends - destroying ships
Posted: 2021-Oct-01 09:22

Ah, well found, missed that! Thanks guys.

Judge
LoI&F: Seasons 10 and 11 King
France WCup team
2021: Bronze
2022: Silver

Please log in to use the reply function.